“Thank you for your invitation to review. Did the authors provide the data and the code they have used to produce the paper? If not, can you ask them to? Please make sure that the authors have their data and code available, so that I will be able to evaluate the manuscript. Otherwise, I will have to decline.” This is my rerevised Conditional Review Acceptance Policy (CRAP – R2). In 2014, I introduced a conditional review acceptance policy.